Electronic medical devices and applications are on the rise. New diagnostic tools to detect cancers and other internal health issues, as well as implantable and wearable devices to detect physical anomalies, make adjustments to heart rhythms, and automatically report to your doctor via the internet, are just a few examples of market growth and opportunities. The research firm Fortune Business Insights noted that “The global medical devices market size was valued at USD 572.31 billion in 2025 and is projected to grow from USD 604.99 billion in 2026 to USD 1032.66 billion by 2034, exhibiting a CAGR of 6.90% during the forecast period.”
Of course, all of these devices need reliable, repeatable test strategies to meet the accuracy, quality, and safety requirements of government agencies such as the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the European Medicines Agency (EMA). Because of the sheer volume of devices, Automated Test Equipment (ATE) is usually required for fast, repeatable testing. The test engineers who program these ATE Test systems determine which parameters need to be tested, the required reporting of results, and overall test times to define how many ATE systems are needed to handle the predicted production volume.
This article will focus on the switching portion of an ATE system, specifically suggesting some questions to ask as you select the necessary switching. Then we will look at some testing applications applicable to virtually any medical device test, and finally focus on the requirements for specific medical device applications.
Switching Considerations
PXI is the world's most widely adopted industry-standard modular ATE platform, and a search for "PXI switching" returns thousands of available modules. That breadth reflects a fundamental constraint: no single relay technology satisfies the full range of voltage, power, and bandwidth requirements across a test system. Relay topology is also critical, since matrix, multiplexer, and general-purpose configurations each impose different trade-offs in signal-routing flexibility, crosstalk, and insertion loss.
Cost and channel density further constrain the choice. If your application calls for a 4x8 matrix, specifying that exact topology avoids paying for an 8x8 module and stranding half of its crosspoints, and it also reduces parasitic loading from unused paths. Building an effective test strategy starts with a complete signal specification: input/output signal counts, maximum switched voltage and current, carry and hot-switch ratings, required bandwidth and characteristic impedance, and acceptable thermal offset, which are typically included in a test plan.
Being armed with the necessary specifications to test is the start. The relay types you select can affect accuracy and even the test system’s lifespan. The most popular relay types used in commercially available PXI switching are Electro-mechanical (EMR), Reed Relay, Solid State, Micro-Electromechanical Systems (MEMS), and Microwave relays.
- Electromechanical Relays (EMRs): Medium cost, wide variety of voltage and current specs, but the lack of package hermetic sealing means airborne contamination can coat the contacts, potentially affecting low-level signal switching consistency and measurement accuracy. Medium switch time (typ 3 ms) and relay life (typ 1 X 107 operations). Available in high-density general-purpose switching (typ 2 A), high-power (up to 40 A), and RF (up to 3 GHz).
- Reed Relays: Higher cost; sealed glass envelope (filled with inert gas or, in the case of high-voltage reed switches, a vacuum) around the contacts to eliminate contamination. These are available in general-purpose, high-voltage (up to 7 kV), RF (up to 1 GHz), and switched-guard low-leakage versions. Reed relays have limited current capability (typ 1 A), long mechanical life (typ 1 X 109), fast switch time (typ 250 us), and excellent low-level switching reliability. They require internal screening to minimize magnetic interference with adjacent relays in high-density designs.
- Solid State Relays: A wide variety for different applications. Very fast switch time, virtually infinite life, but a compromise between relay-closed resistance and capacitance, and excessive leakage if the voltage spec is exceeded. Available in high-density low-cost switching (low signal), RF (up to 8 GHz), and high power (up to 40 A).
- MEMS Switches: 6 GHz RF switches currently available, high cost, controlled impedance (50 Ω), very fast switch time (typ. 50 µS), and long relay life (Typ. 3 × 10^9). But limited power capacity.
- Microwave EMRs: Highest cost, very high bandwidth (up to 110 GHz) and excellent RF specs, high RF carry power (up to 400 W), controlled impedance (50 or 75 Ω), medium cycle times (typ 15 ms), but relatively low mechanical life (10 to 50 million cycles).
The table below summarizes how PXI modules fitted with each relay type perform across the key selection criteria. Note that figures are typical values and vary by manufacturer and specific part.
| Specification | EMR | Reed | Solid State | MEMS | Microwave EMR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost per switch | Medium | High | Low for low signal switches. High for RF and Power. | High | Highest |
| Closure / Switch Time | Medium, 3 ms to more than 20 ms | Fast, 80 µs to 500 µs | Very fast, depending on type - range from ns to 10’s of µs | Very fast, typ. 50 µs | Slow, Typ. 15 ms |
| Leakage | Very Low | Very Low | Low to many µa, depending on type | Very Low | Very Low |
| Relay Life (Operations) | Medium,100 million operations under light load, usually drops to 1 million at full load. | High under light load conditions (Pickering instrument grade reeds last 1 billion or more operations) | Virtually infinite when operated within specifications. | High (typ 3×10⁹) | Low (10 to 50 million cycles) |
| Switching Current | Low to High. Wide range of specs | Very low to medium. Excellent contact repeatability under low operating currents. | Low to High. High power switches can sustain high inrush currents | Limited power capacity | Low (typ 1 A) |
| Switching Voltage | Can be high | Can be very high – up to 7 kV for PXI and 20 kV for discrete reed relays | Low to high | Under 100 volts | Typ 100 V |
| Operating Frequency | Can be up to 3 GHz but most designs are limited to 100’s MHz | Simple switching systems to 1 GHz, often limited to below this frequency | Limited by capacitance trade-off | Typ 6 GHz | Up to 110 GHz |
From this brief comparison, it is clear that solid-state relays offer a very long service life under operating conditions within their rating range. They can withstand short-term overloads without damage, but if abused, they can quickly fail catastrophically. They are ideal for high-speed applications involving many operations. Reed relays offer the best performance under lighter load conditions, with a high service life and repeatable performance even when lightly loaded. EMRs can control higher power levels but have a more limited mechanical life. Under light load conditions, EMRs relays can exhibit variable contact performance. They can also be the lowest cost solution.
Another important specification to consider early in the system design is relay life. The specifications of a switch module will list the number of operations across low- to high-power ranges. Also, look closely at your test program and see how often a relay is cycled in a single test run. We have had customers assume that the cycle count is based on how many test runs are executed, rather than on how many times a relay is used per test run. In this situation, the switch modules could be wearing out faster than expected.
General Applications
Every medical device has specific parameters that must be tested, and these can differ from those of other devices. We will elaborate on several of these testing applications later in the article, however, there are several switching applications that apply to virtually any medical device. Portions of a device's overall test strategy will likely include these tests and the associated switching required.
Hipot Testing
A Hipot test is essentially a high-voltage ohmmeter. It is also called High Potential or Dielectric Withstand Testing. The idea is to apply a high-voltage source, which could be a few hundred to a few thousand volts, either AC or DC, and then monitor any leakage current. This leakage could be caused by poor insulation or the improper assembly of the device. This test is designed to eliminate any leakage that exceeds the device specification, which can cause poor performance or even exhibit a lethal shock hazard. According to the IEC specification 60950, the applied Hipot voltage is typically twice the device’s operating voltage plus 1,000 volts. When selecting high-voltage switching, ensure the switching's standoff voltage exceeds the maximum hipot voltage to prevent it from contributing to any leakage measurements. The same care applies to cabling and connectors, which also require a high-standoff-voltage specification.
Fault Insertion
During the development phase of a medical device, or after any firmware update or design change, it is common to run the device or devices through a series of functional tests. This could be a hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) test that evaluates the DUT’s ability to work with other devices under real-life conditions. During these long-term testing tactics, one additional verification tactic is to include Fault Insertion (FI) switches. The FI switching tests the devices for known bad situations that may not be tested in a production test environment due to test time limitations. For example, how will the device react to an open sensor cable or a short of two wires when insulation fails? It is important to know that the device does no harm to patients when a failure is observed. There are many options for FI switching. What is important from a specification standpoint is that the signal path does not cause issues in no-fail or pass-through mode. Also, bandwidth and impedance may be important for high-speed buses. Finally, what kind of faults need to be tested? Opens, shorts, and faulty signals are several areas where FI switching excels.
HALT/HASS
A very long-term test strategy involves one or more Devices Under Test (DUTs) in an environmental chamber during a Highly Accelerated Life Test (HALT) or Highly Accelerated Stress Screening (HASS) test. During these long-term testing tactics, the devices will undergo a full functional test many times. Of course, switching will most likely be used to assign test resources to potentially many devices under test, usually in the form of high-density matrices. As these tests can range from a few days to even months, be sure that the switching has an adequate cycle-count specification. In many cases, solid-state switching may be implemented as these devices have virtually limitless cycle counts.
Focused Applications
Hipot for Implantable Devices
When a company is manufacturing Implantable medical devices such as Pacemakers and Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillators (ICDs), Hipot testing is performed on the device and its leads to detect issues such as a faulty device case, nicked or crushed insulation on leads, stray wire strands, conductive contaminants, and inadequate spacing between terminals. Typical Hipot voltages are in the 2-4 kV range. Device manufacturers are either purchasing high-voltage reed relays and building the necessary switching to test multiple devices or implementing a modular test strategy using commercially available switching. If your organization is implementing the former strategy, engineers who understand the issues associated with very high-voltage switching and cabling will be key to your success.
In the relatively new field of Pulsed Field Ablation (PFA), the latest technique for performing cardiac ablation for atrial fibrillation (Afib) uses short bursts of high-voltage electrical pulses to repair cardiac cells that cause Afib. Manufacturers are looking at higher voltages for Hipot testing of the PFA catheters. Voltages as high as 20 kV are needed for this test.
Hearing Aids
Hearing aid products cover a broad spectrum of features and requirements. They range from a simple amplifier to an implantable direct-to-brain connection of a cochlear implant. Except for a cochlear implant, amplification and audio quality are the primary goals. Advanced signal processing to filter out noise and optimize speech understanding is a must in the most advanced hearing aids. So, the ability to generate a clean audio signal and capture the amplified signal for comparison is the focus. The switching will clearly be at audio frequencies, and the inputs and outputs will be at different voltage levels.
Other features to test include:
- Bluetooth: Virtually all of today’s hearing aids have a Bluetooth connection to the user’s phone for changing audio parameters, taking phone calls, and listening to television. So, 2.5 GHz switching is needed here.
- Battery Charging: Testing the hearing aid’s ability to detect battery levels and control charging will require a battery/charging simulator to emulate the device’s battery.
As hearing aids are high-volume manufactured products, the European Hearing Instrument Manufacturers Association (EHIMA) sold 23.16 million hearing aids worldwide in 2025, parallel testing systems are required. Redundant instruments and proper switching enable fast, repeatable testing.
In the case of cochlear implants, audio quality is not the focus, but rather the A/D conversion in the speech processor and the RF transmission between the implant and the external device. Typically, this is a 5 MHz signal that transmits data and also charges the implant battery. The other Bluetooth and battery-charging tests will be the same as those for normal hearing aids.
MRI Receive-Only Coils
In Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), receive-only (R/O) RF coils are antennas designed to detect the weak MR signal from the patient. They are typically small, surface-based coils placed close to the anatomy of interest to maximize signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Like any Medical device, the FDA and NEMA dictate the types of electrical tests required. These include:
- Signal-to-Noise Ratio to validate the coil’s baseline sensitivity
- Image Uniformity Tests for consistent signal strength across the field of view
- Acquired Image Quality to assess artifact levels and diagnostic clarity
- Immunity/Electrostatic Discharge to test the coil’s resilience to interference and static shocks
- Decoupling Circuit to ensure the coil turns off during RF transmission to prevent burns
- Surface Heating measures RF-induced temperature changes to ensure patient safety
Many of these test sequences can be slow, with total test times of up to several minutes. Fortunately, these coils are not manufactured at very high volumes compared to medical implantable and wearable devices. But to minimize operator intervention and ensure repeatability, multiple devices are connected to an RF multiplexer to switch the necessary instruments to each coil as needed. The RF multiplexer, with the proper cabling, assures repeatable measurements between coils. The bandwidth is relatively low, as these coils operate in the Lamor bandwidth, with tests typically at 63.87 MHz and 127.74 MHz and measurements in the first two harmonics, so the limit is around 600 MHz. Signal levels will be low, so ensure the signal path resistance is as low as possible, which suggests using reed relays. If the test specs require maximum isolation and minimum loss, high-bandwidth microwave switching is recommended.
Conclusion
Medical device testing benefits from selecting the proper switching for each circuit and application. The result is a test strategy that is fast, accurate, and repeatable. As you can see from the examples shown, there are many choices to get the test absolutely correct from the product. There are many other products that will benefit from switching in their test strategy, and similar questions and selections apply. Whether you purchase modular switching or design your own, test plans and specifications will help you select the best switching for each application.
Discover more about medical device testing solutions here.
Or contact us to learn how Pickering's switching and simulation solutions can help optimize your medical device test systems.