Pole Switched Matrices | Efficient Relay Switching Explained
Crosspoint matrices are constructed using arrays of SPST relays arranged in a simple grid formation. On the other hand, Tree Matrices leverage Tree Multiplexers to address the needs of systems requiring high RF bandwidth. However, while these designs can optimize performance, they also limit the connectivity they can offer.
(Find more information on Crosspoint and Tree Matrices)
Another variation includes crosspoint matrices with an added twist: the crosspoint array is segmented by isolation relays. This design provides matrices with intermediate bandwidths, balancing connectivity and performance.
We employ a unique type of matrix designed not for increased bandwidth, but to enhance density and reduce relay count. This approach, most effective for systems using EMRs, is known as the Pole Switched Matrix or, alternatively, the Efficient Matrix.
Pole Switched Matrix
Many commercially available EMRs are designed as DPDT (Double Pole Double Throw) relays. Each unit contains two mechanically linked changeover relays, represented by a dotted line in their schematic.
The crosspoint switches on Y1 and Y2 are two-pole relays housed within the same package (a DPDT relay is used for an EMR). This design pattern is consistently applied throughout the system. Connections are established from X via the SPDT relay, which then routes through the crosspoint relay when activated. The SPDT relay ensures that only the odd or even Y axis connects to the X line, depending on its position.
While effective, this arrangement introduces certain limitations to the matrix's connectivity. Each X connection can link to either an odd or an even Y axis, but not both simultaneously, without causing routing conflicts. For instance, if X2 is connected to Y1, the changeover mechanism prevents it from also connecting to Y2. This limitation, however, does not occur when SPST relays are used.
In a Y=6 matrix, a traditional crosspoint switch requires 6 relays per X connection. In contrast, the Pole Switched arrangement achieves the same connection using just 4 relays—one changeover relay and three crosspoint relays—resulting in a notable reduction in relay usage. This efficiency allows for larger matrices within the same PCB footprint.
Example: For a Y=6 matrix and a system accommodating 256 relays, a standard configuration could support a 42x6 matrix. However, with the Pole Switched design, the same setup could accommodate a 64x6 matrix. This efficiency could enable the entire matrix to fit within a single PXI slot instead of requiring two slots.
Connection Limitations
To streamline the use of Pole Switched Matrices, our driver restricts connections that would link two Y connections to the same X connection. While this limitation could be more flexible (for instance, in the diagram above, X1 could connect to both Y1 and Y3), the simplified functionality ensures easier operation.
In most cases, users don’t connect directly to the Y axis of large matrices. Instead, both the system instrumentation and the unit under test are typically connected through the X axis. This approach ensures the matrix size is determined solely by the number of concurrent paths required for each test, making the system more efficient and practical to use.
Using X axis connections to limit Y axis size to the number of concurrent connections required
For users who do not require access to the Y connections, the Pole Switched Matrix offers unrestricted connectivity. Shorts (equivalent to Y-to-Y connections when the instruments are set to Y) can be applied seamlessly across the instrumentation connections.
However, for users who do need access to the Y connections, a practical solution is available. Using the 256-relay Y=6 example, it is recommended to designate X1 to X6 for Y access. The remaining 58 X connections (out of 64) can then be utilized for the X-axis connections. This approach maintains full connectivity without limitations while enabling a matrix size significantly larger than what is possible with a simple crosspoint matrix.
That said, this method may introduce additional complexity in PCB tracking, potentially requiring an increase in the number of PCB layers in some cases. Nonetheless, it remains an efficient way to balance flexibility and scalability.
Data Sheet Depiction
The only prohibited path type is shown in red, where two Y connections are linked via the same X connection. This configuration lacks practical applications and is therefore disallowed. However, if users utilize X-axis connections to access Y, this limitation no longer applies. For instance, by closing connections X1Y1, X2Y2, X3Y3, X4Y4, X5Y5, and X6Y6—effectively transforming X1 to X6 into Y1 to Y6—links between any Y connections become fully permissible.