Test Engineer’s Guide to Lowering Total Cost of Ownership
As test professionals, we are focused on a single, critical objective: ensuring the products our companies build are reliable
and meet the highest quality standards. We need test systems that are scalable, accurate, efficient, and cost-effective.
The decisions we make, or recommend, have long-term consequences for our project timelines, budgets, and overall success.
When we analyze test and measurement hardware from this perspective, the differences are apparent. Below are insights we’ve
gained by comparing some of our specific PXI products to those of NI/Emerson. The data reveals a consistent pattern where
the value goes far beyond the initial purchase price.
Ultra-High-Density Matrix Switch Module
In high-channel-count applications, rack space and density are critical. We compared our 40-540A with the NI PXIe-2532B, both single-slot PXI modules with more than 500 crosspoints.
| Attribute |
Pickering 40-540A |
NI PXIe-2532B |
| Bus |
PXI |
PXIe |
| Crosspoints |
528 |
512 |
| Max VDC |
150V |
100V |
| Max Current |
0.5A |
0.5A |
|
Max Simultaneous Relay closures
(important for shorts/opens testing)
|
135 |
64 |
| Deterministic handshaking |
No |
Yes |
| Reed Relay type |
Instrumentation-Grade Ruthenium Reed Relays |
Standard Rhodium Reed Relays |
| External Terminal Block Required |
No |
Yes |
| Field Diagnostic Tools Available |
Yes eBIRST
|
No |
| Spare relays onboard |
Yes – through-hole packaging (easier to repair than the 2532B’s SMT relays) |
No |
| Standard Warranty |
3 Years |
1 Year |
| Direct Technical Support |
Included |
With support contract |
| Lifecycle |
20+ years |
Varies* |
| 2020 Price |
$5,605 |
$7,386 |
| 2026 Price** |
$9,475 |
$14,354 |
Aside from the price difference (almost $5,000), our 40-540A module offers more crosspoints and a higher maximum voltage.
Another key differentiator is the availability of field diagnostics and accelerated repair via spare relays included
on the board. This is a practical feature that simplifies maintenance and minimizes downtime without voiding the warranty.
Then there’s the support structure. We include a standard three-year hardware warranty and direct technical support for the
life of the product at no additional cost. With NI, the standard warranty is only one year, and after that, hardware
and software support require separate, paid contracts. When we factor in our 20+ year lifecycle versus NI's unknown lifecycle,
the long-term reliability is evident.
High-Density Multiplexer Switch Module
Next, we looked at high-density multiplexers, where we compared our 42-675B to the NI PXIe-2575.
| Attribute |
Pickering 42-675B |
NI PXIe-2575 |
| Bus |
PXIe |
PXIe |
| Channels |
198 |
196 |
| Max VDC |
150V |
100V |
| Max Current |
1A |
1A |
| Deterministic handshaking |
No |
Yes |
| Reed Relay type |
EMR |
EMR |
| External Terminal Block Required |
No |
No |
| Field Diagnostic Tools Available |
Yes eBIRST
|
No |
| Spare relays onboard |
Yes |
No |
| Standard Warranty |
3 Years |
1 Year |
| Direct Technical Support |
Included |
With support contract |
| Lifecycle |
20+ years |
Varies* |
| 2020 Price |
$1,960 |
$2,562 |
| 2026 Price** |
$3,140 |
$4,982 |
Here, a similar story unfolds. Our module provides more channels and a higher voltage tolerance. Again, we include onboard
spare relays, a three-year warranty, direct support, and we’re almost $2,000 less expensive.
General Purpose Switch Module
For high-density, single-slot PXI general-purpose relay modules, the comparison between our 42-145A and the NI PXIe-2569 continues the trend.
| Attribute |
Pickering 42-145A |
NI PXIe-2569 |
| Bus |
PXIe |
PXIe |
| Channels |
100 |
100 |
| Max VDC |
150V |
100V |
| Max Current |
1A |
1A |
| Deterministic handshaking |
No |
Yes |
| Reed Relay type |
EMR |
EMR |
| External Terminal Block Required |
No |
No |
| Field Diagnostic Tools Available |
Yes eBIRST
|
No |
| Spare relays onboard |
Yes |
No |
| Standard Warranty |
3 Years |
1 Year |
| Direct Technical Support |
Included |
With support contract |
| Lifecycle |
20+ years |
Varies* |
| 2020 Price |
$1,645 |
$2,323 |
| 2026 Price** |
$2,645 |
$4,517 |
While both modules offer 100 relays, our module provides a higher voltage tolerance, onboard spare relays for simplified
maintenance, and a standard three-year warranty with included support. The price difference further solidifies its position
as the more cost-effective and reliable choice.
Industrial Digital Input Module
Higher-voltage digital input modules are critical for connecting industrial sensors and control systems. Here, we compare
our 42-414 against
the NI PXI-6529.
| Attribute |
Pickering 42-414 |
NI PXI-6529 |
| Bus |
PXIe |
PXI |
| Digital Input Channels |
64 |
48 |
| Max VDC |
100V |
60V |
| Ch-Ch Isolation |
No |
Yes |
| Programmable Thresholds |
Yes |
No |
| Standard Warranty |
3 Years |
1 Year |
| Direct Technical Support |
Included |
With support contract |
| Lifecycle |
20+ years |
Varies* |
| 2020 Price |
N/A |
$918 |
| 2026 Price** |
$1,825 |
$1,845 |
A significant technical advantage is our programmable thresholds capability, which offer greater flexibility in configuring
the system for different logic levels. In practice, this means you can use our digital input module, rather than multiple,
expensive DMMs, to validate that a device-under-test has achieved specific voltage levels. While the price is nearly
identical, our module delivers superior channel density, higher voltage, and advanced technical features, all backed
by a longer warranty and included support, making it the clear value leader.
High-Density Precision Resistor Module
Simulating resistive sensors is a standard testing requirement, so we also examined resistor modules. This comparison was
between our 42-297A and
the NI PXIe-2727.
| Attribute |
Pickering 42-297A |
NI PXIe-2727 |
| Bus |
PXIe |
PXIe |
| Number of Channels |
6 |
9 |
| Maximum Resistance |
201 kΩ |
16 kΩ |
| Resistance Resolution |
0.25 Ω |
0.25 Ω |
| Short/Open Simulation |
Yes |
No |
| Standard Warranty |
3 Years |
1 Year |
| Direct Technical Support |
Included |
With support contract |
| Lifecycle |
20+ years |
Varies* |
| 2020 Price |
$3,565 |
$3,931 |
| 2026 Price** |
$5,710 |
$7,640 |
While the NI module has three more channels, our module offers more than 12 times the resistance range. This flexibility
is crucial for simulating a wider variety of sensors without needing additional hardware. Our module also includes the
ability to simulate short and open circuits, a vital feature for comprehensive fault testing that is absent in the NI
counterpart.
Advantages of a Partner-Centric Model
Across every category we analyzed, the pattern held. We consistently deliver modules with competitive or superior performance
specifications, coupled with features that directly address the practical needs of test engineers. Onboard spare relays,
longer warranties, included expert support, and a commitment to product lifecycles of twenty years or more are not minor
details. They are foundational elements of a low-risk, cost-effective test strategy.
This approach speaks to our deeper philosophy: not just as a vendor but as a partner in your success. The long lifecycle
commitment means we can design a system today with confidence that we’ll be able to get support and replacements for
decades, avoiding costly redesigns forced by component obsolescence. The included technical support ensures that if we
run into an issue, you can speak directly with an expert who understands the hardware, saving you valuable time and eliminating
the need for a separate support contract.
PXI Switching Subsystem Comparison
Lastly, we’ve outlined a high-density, modular switching and measurement solution for automated testing across mixed-signal,
power, and precision measurement applications. The configuration includes general-purpose and high-power relay switching,
DMM multiplexing, 4-wire matrix resources, and high-bandwidth oscilloscope multiplexing to meet a wide range of test
requirements. Our Pickering-based solution is compared with functionally equivalent competitor solution, focusing on
total system cost, channel density, and slot efficiency to identify the most cost-effective implementation.
|
PXI Switching Requirements
|
| GP SPST Relay : 100 channels @ 2A |
| GP SPDT Relay: 100 channels @2A |
| DMM Mux: 128 2-pole channels @300V/2A |
| Power SPST: 30 channels @ 12A |
| 4-wire, 1-pole Matrix: 250 channels |
| Dual 1x8 Scope Mux, 2.5 GHz |
| 2 Slots 111x SPST, 2A/150V |
| Competitor Solution |
PICKERING Solution |
PICKERING Advantage |
| 2 Slots 111x SPST, 2A/150V |
2 Slots 112x SPST, 2A 300V |
Summary
300V vs 150V
|
| 2 Slots 106x SPST, 2A/100V |
2 Slots 104x SPDT, 2A/300V |
300V vs 100V |
| 4 Slots 128x ch 2-pole, 300V/2A |
2 Slots 128x 2-pole, 2A/300V |
Two slot reduction |
| 3 Slots 30x SPST, 12A |
2 Slots 32x SPST, 16A |
16A vs 12A in one less slot |
| 2 Slots 4x 256, 1-pole |
2 Slots 4x276, 1-pole |
No external wiring required |
| 1 Slot 2x SP8T, 2.7GHz |
1 Slot 2x SP8T, 3GHz |
Increased bandwidth |
|
1 Slot 1x Dual SPDT, 26.5 GHz
4 Slot 2x Dual SP6T, 26.5 GHz
|
1 Slot 1x Dual SPDT, 26.5 GHz
4 Slots 2x Dual SP4T, 26.5 GHz
|
No unused ports, LED indicators |
| 19 Total PXI Chassis Slots |
16 Total PXI Chassis Slots |
Three less chassis slots |
|
Total Cost $98k **
|
Total Cost $59k **
|
>30% cost reduction
|
Final Calculation: Beyond The Price Tag
As engineers, we are trained to analyze data and make informed decisions. When we look beyond the initial price and consider
the total cost of ownership, the choice becomes even clearer. Our offering provides a more reliable and efficient solution,
with better performance, practical features, robust support, and transparent pricing.
For us, choosing a component is an investment in the future success of your test system. It’s about minimizing downtime,
ensuring compatibility for years to come, and providing the support you need when you need it.
* “Technology evolution, market demand, and component obsolescence dictate the lifecycle of a given NI hardware product.” Source: https://www.ni.com/en/support/hardware-product-life-cycle-policies.html
** Prices are as of January, 20 2026.
Design, Deploy & Sustain
Streamline the lifecycle of your electronic test and verification system