When a US-based engineering company needed a high-reliability, programmable RF switching subsystem for an ATE system, they turned to Pickering Interfaces.
Supporting Legacy
Within the aerospace and defense sector, there is a growing need and market for maintaining legacy systems. This is not surprising, as some systems in use today entered service decades ago. However, failing components (ones that are long obsolete) put the maintenance and, therefore, continued operation of the systems at risk. Indeed, given the reduced lifecycle of many modern electronic components, even newer systems can face obsolescence challenges.
Accordingly, it is often necessary to reverse engineer parts of a system (such as PCBs or line replaceable units, LRUs) and build form-fit-function replacements. There is also often a need to modernize legacy systems and to add new features and capabilities, particularly in the defense sector.
One company serving this growing market is based in the US. It supports a variety of civilian and military agencies through a range of specialized engineering services, which include designing and building automated test equipment (ATE) systems. Recently, the company needed a programmable RF Interface Unit (RFIU) subsystem for an ATE to test multiple RF transmit/receive (T/R) elements that operate up to 18 GHz.
Specifically, a switching matrix was needed that could simultaneously connect up to four RF instruments—such as spectrum and signal analyzers and signal sources—to nine different RF T/R elements.
For ease of connecting the instruments and T/R elements, the company wanted the matrix’s inputs and outputs to be presented on a MacPanel interface. The company also wanted to control the matrix with software written in C++ and to have a clear visual indication of the RFIU’s configuration: i.e., which inputs are connected to which outputs.
High reliability and repeatability (in terms of amplitude and phase) were also key requirements, and Pickering Interfaces was one of several potential suppliers approached to submit a proposal.
The Pickering Proposition
Pickering Interfaces designs and manufactures scalable switching and routing solutions for applications from DC to light. These solutions can easily be integrated into test systems that incorporate PXI, LXI, or USB communications interfaces back to a host computer.
The turnkey solution Pickering proposed in this instance was an LXI rack-mount enclosure containing multiple interconnected RF switches (with which the switching matrix would be created) that could be controlled via Ethernet/LAN from the ATE’s host controller.
In terms of the switching matrix, Pickering presented three options:
- A 9 x 4 matrix capable of DC to 18 GHz, with an option to extend the frequency to 26.5 GHz. The matrix would be built using four single-pole, double-throw (SPDT) and 17 single-pole, six-throw (SP6T) switches. The input-to-output signal path would pass through three RF switches.
- A 10 x 5 matrix capable of DC to 18 GHz and extending to 26.5 GHz if needed. This matrix would require five SPDT switches and 20 SP6T switches. Again, the input-to-output signal path would pass through three RF switches.
- A modified architecture (12 x 2 x 8), in case the customer wanted the ability for even greater expansion: up to 12 T/Rs and up to 8 instruments, although only two I/O path connections would be available simultaneously. The input-to-output signal path would pass through four RF switches. This was proposed purely as food for thought, as the required hardware cost would be in the same ballpark as options 1 and 2.
Pickering also ran a series of tests on three and four interconnected switches to illustrate the performance that could be expected from each of the three proposed topologies. The test results, in the form of Voltage Standing Wave Radio (VSWR) plots, are shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1. A VSWR plot is used to show how the impedance of an antenna or transmission line matches a source, and how much signal is reflected. Above are the VSWR plots for three (left) and four (right) interconnected switches.
While option 1 met the company’s immediate requirements, option 2 (the 10 x 5 matrix) was selected as accommodating future expansion was of interest. Also, ahead of any expansion that might take place, any unused switch ports would provide a level of redundancy: i.e., if any single switch failed, the RFIU could remain fully functional in terms of connecting up to four instruments to up to nine T/Rs. Figure 2 shows the topology.
Figure 2 – This 10 x 5 matrix met the customer’s immediate requirements. It also provides redundancy or the ability to add a fifth instrument and a tenth T/R element. Note, it was also a requirement that any unused input or output should have a programmable path to a 50Ω termination.
The RFIU
Following the customer's acceptance of the modelled RF characteristics and the 3D model of the chassis, the design was signed off, and the RFIU entered Pickering's manufacturing process. It also entered Pickering’s rigorous obsolescence management system, which assures the availability of COTS parts (such as the RF switches) throughout the agreed-upon lifecycle of the product, which can be 20 years or more in some cases.
The RFIU was built, thoroughly tested and delivered (along with technical documentation) within just a few months of placing the order. Figures 3 and 4 show the final product.
Figure 3 – Above left, the LXI chassis’ rear panel. It meets the customer’s request for easy access to the switching matrix’s inputs and outputs (achieved using 15 SMA connectors). The chassis complies with LXI Standard 1.5 and has a 1000Base-T Ethernet interface (via a standard RJ-45 connector) and an LCD display to show the unit’s IP address.
Figure 3 – Above right, the chassis front panel. LEDs in the schematic indicate which switches are closed (energized paths). Additional LEDs (in the bottom left-hand corner) convey the LXI Ethernet status: conditions include powering up, normal operating status, network failure, ServerBridge failure and Ethernet change notification.
The hardware was supplied with a LAN communications interface, which is common to all Pickering’s LXI products. Pickering also supplied:
- A Soft Front Panel manual programming interface is also common across all Pickering switching products and includes software drivers compatible with most application development environments, including C# (meeting the customer’s programming requirements).
- A Switch Path Manager (SPM) application programmer’s interface. It is specific to the 10 x 5 configuration shown in Figure 1. Signal routing through the SPM API is performed by simply defining test system endpoints to be connected.
Summary
The customer received a highly reliable and repeatable turnkey RFIU subsystem, thoroughly tested and documented, for its ATE. The switching matrix at the heart of the RFIU can accommodate more I/O if necessary, and thanks to the versatility of the SPM, programming is significantly simplified.
Also, the VSWR tests that were performed leading up to the design being signed off have since been simulated in Pickering’s Microwave Switch Design Tool (MSDT) - a free online resource enabling engineers to easily design, simulate, and model PXI and LXI microwave switching systems – and the results track extremely well. See Figure 5.
Figure 5: Simulated vs. actual VSWR performance for the 10x5, 18 GHz matrix.
Since the launch of MSDT, all projects like the one recounted here require the customer to approve performance simulations and 3D models before any design can move into production. Pre-production RF (signal path) characterization tests can still be performed upon request.
On a final note, Pickering has most recently made the 18 GHz, 50 Ω characteristic impedance,10 x 5 matrix RFIU into a standard COTS product (part number 60-891-048). It is an LXI standard 1.4-compliant matrix in a 3U form factor with a three-year warranty.